Sports
JOHN D'ONOFRIO: Flutie-Johnson debate rages on
COMMENTARY
If there’s one thing that Doug Flutie’s retirement proved this week, it’s the fact that time has done nothing to heal the wounds suffered by Buffalo Bills fans in the ongoing and always lively and enthusiastic Flutie versus Rob Johnson debate.
I feel sorry for the younger Bills fans who can’t appreciate the intensity of the argument that began in the late 1990s when quarterbacks Johnson and Flutie first emerged on the Western New York scene.
Fresh off the Jim Kelly versus Frank Reich debate that paled in comparison — but existed nonetheless in the years leading up to Kelly’s and Reich’s retirements — the uproar over who the Bills’ new starting QB should be in the next era was far less cut and dry.
There was always a good case to be made for each player:
n Flutie, the Heisman Trophy-winning miracle worker with an intoxicating love of the game.
n Johnson, the man with all the tools, especially the proper height and a golden arm.
The debate began the moment the Bills named Johnson the starter before the start of the 1998 season. Johnson stumbled (literally), Flutie took over the starting spot and the team started winning. The debate then carried over into the following season and spread out quickly to the rest of the country.
Arguments raged day and night, by not only avid football fans, but casual ones as well, including housewives, grandmothers, farmers, businessmen, holy men, teachers, judges and politicians. Everyone — even the guy standing next to you waiting for the bus, or the lady serving you two eggs over easy and a side of white toast, or your five-year-old daughter — had an opinion on the matter.
How either Flutie or Johnson played from one week to the next also did little to diminish the intensity of our partisan allegiance, because most importantly, you either liked one or the other. No one liked both. You neither hated both. It was always one or the other.
Nothing. Not their separate post-Buffalo Bills careers, not their insistence that time together on the Bills was a long and forgotten saga in their lives, nor the passage of time have ever altered our perspective of how we viewed them, which is — ironically — collectively.
The departure of both Flutie and Johnson and the emergence of Drew Bledsoe as the Bills new (and only) quarterback temporarly put the Flutie-Johnson debate to rest, but even Drew couldn’t erase them from our minds. Flutie’s announced retirement this week proved it again.
I found it astonishing how grown men and women in their 40s, 50s and 60s took up sides in the newsroom this past week with just the mention of Flutie’s name. The presidential debates, the economy, the price of gas, not even the smoking ban, generated more intense vocal outbursts.
How unfortunate that two talented players could leave such a distorted legacy, but that’s how we’ll always remember Flutie — and Johnson. Their rivalry and its negative and long-lasting impact.
Contact John D’Onofrio at 439-9222 Ext. 6247 or donofrioj@gnnewspaper.com.
- Sports
-
-
Polk, pork spark Lockport past Starpoint
It took Dorian Polk less than 10 seconds to prove his worth to the Lockport football program for the last half decade.
-
Kojsza, Schneider lead boys volleyball Lions
The numbers and hopes remain high at boys volleyball preseason camp for Lockport Lions head coach Chris Niver.
-
Hail to GC Presidents
The big play Grover Cleveland Presidents were just a little too much for the Wilson Lakemen to handle Friday night in their Section VI Class C North football opener.
-
Lady Lions spikers feature size and strength
Tall, quick on their feet and strong, the 2010 Lockport High School girls volleyball team features some of the best female athletes not only at LHS, but throughout the area.
-
LHS Lady swim Lions look to make a big splash
Thanks to a plethora of local feeder programs which keep churning out tremendous young talent, Lockport High School girls varsity swim coach Kristen Allen remains optimistic over the upcoming Niagara Frontier League pool season.
-
Brownsten sparkles in debut
Lockport’s Cory Brownsten made the most of his promotion by the Atlanta Braves to the Appalachian League this week.
-
Lions beat Bills 28-23 in preseason finale
Matthew Stafford had an interception returned for a touchdown, but third-stringer Drew Stanton threw a pair of second-half touchdown passes to lift the Detroit Lions to a 28-23 win over the Buffalo Bills in their preseason finale Thursday night.
-
Grand Finale
Lockport High School golf head coach Dave Gilson wants to see history repeat itself this year — and in more than one way.
-
LLLF Bucs tame the Lions at ‘Alumni Bowl’
The Lockport Little Loop Bucs can claim bragging rights and the coveted Alumni Bowl trophy as they defeated the Pendleton Lions, 38-20, Saturday, in the sixth-annual “Alumni Bowl”
-
Opportunity knocks
With the loss to graduation of their top two singles players and one half of their first doubles tandem, the Lockport High School girls tennis team will see plenty of fresh, young talented faces in 2010.
- More Sports Headlines
-
