The Niagara County Industrial Development Agency will ask the state’s highest court for permission to appeal a recent ruling that nullified the agency’s tax break agreement with AES Corp. in Somerset.
Following an hour-long executive session Wednesday afternoon, IDA board members directed their outside legal counsel, Richard Sullivan of the Harris Beach firm, to formally request that the Court of Appeals review the findings of the State Supreme Court Appellate Division, Fourth Judicial Department.
The Appellate Division issued a ruling last week that invalidated a 12-year, $192 million payment-in-lieu-of taxes deal between the agency and the owners of the Somerset power plant.
IDA officials expressed fears that provisions of the ruling could prevent the agency from accomplishing one of its core missions — attracting new development projects through incentive programs.
“The implications of the decision are so very broad in terms of how IDAs operate in this state and, more specifically, this IDA moving forward and our ability to generate economic development, that we are going to ask for permission that this matter be heard before the Court of Appeals in the state of New York,” IDA Chairman Henry Sloma said.
While IDA officials expressed concern about the potential impact of the court ruling on taxing jurisdictions throughout the county, they said the move to appeal had more to do with what they believe will be the far-reaching consequences of the court’s decision.
Of particular concern to the IDA is a portion of the Appellate Division’s ruling that suggested the PILOT agreement was improper because AES failed to supply the agency with adequate financial information that could have been used by the agency to determine if the tax break was indeed necessary.
IDA officials contend no such requirements are found in current law governing the activities of New York’s economic development agencies. They argue that mandating such cost-benefit determinations for future projects would essentially force IDAs statewide into a situation where they would only be able to do business with companies in which financial hardship can be proven. As a result, IDA officials argue the ruling infringes on their ability to work with companies that are financially well off and looking to grow.
“This eliminates our ability to attract jobs,” IDA attorney Mark Gabriele said. “It only allows us to retain jobs.”
Gabriele said the PILOT agreement will remain in effect pending the outcome of the agency’s legal action. He added that, given the gravity of the court’s decision, the agency expects other IDAs across the state to join in its request for a clarification on the need for future tax break deals to include cost-benefit analysis.
“Our concern is that the decision was overreaching as to what the statute said,” Gabriele said.
The IDA granted the PILOT agreement to AES in exchange for a promise by the company to pursue the construction of a state-subsidized clean coal plant under former Gov. George Pataki’s Advance Clean Coal Initiative. Under the original deal, the company agreed to drop a series of pending lawsuits challenging the Town of Somerset’s annual assessment.
In early 2007, the Town of Somerset, Barker School District and Niagara County sued the IDA and AES in an effort to have the PILOT rescinded. State Supreme Court Justice Richard Kloch dismissed their petitions that year, prompting the school district and town to proceed with an appeal.
On Friday, the State Supreme Court Appellate Division reversed Kloch’s decision, finding multiple flaws in the IDA’s justification for granting the tax break, including lack of evidence supporting the agency’s claim that the deal would compel AES to drop its assessment lawsuits to the benefit of the taxing entities. The court also found that the agency deviated from its uniform tax exemption policy without proper justification for doing so.
The Appellate Division ruling clears the way for AES Somerset to reactivate the lawsuits that sought to challenge the plant’s assessed value. IDA officials have expressed concerns that such legal action could result in local taxing jurisdictions being forced to pay costly tax refunds to the company or that issues surrounding the cost of operating the plant would compel AES to move out of Somerset altogether.
Town officials have expressed an interest in settling the company’s claims out of court.
IDA officials expressed hope such a settlement will be reached in the coming months.
“We have agreed that we stand by our original decision on AES,” Sloma said. “We’re hopeful also that the community under its new leadership would work with the company to come up with a host community agreement, if possible.”
Contact reporter Mark Scheer at 282-2311, ext. 2250.
Local News
AES TAX-BREAK AGREEMENT: IDA to request appeal
County IDA officials want court to revisit PILOT for Somerset power plant
- Local News
-
-
WIlson jumps on the 'bin wagon'
Modern Recycling’s upgraded plan has received a warm response some town residents.
The town plans to go from 14-gallon open bins to 65-gallon carts with lids in April. Modern representatives explained the project, put the recycling truck in action and showed of three 32-pound blue and green carts that can withstand 43 mph winds.
The display carts had transparent sides in order to let the residents know the variety of materials that can be recycled. -
Reform agenda touted
Empire State Development Corporation executive Sam Hoyt visited Lockport on Wednesday to tout Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s state budget and government reform plans.
Changing the way the state does business will bring fiscal relief to counties, cities and towns, eventually, Hoyt suggested.
It’s too bad the reforms won’t kick in before municipalities like the City of Lockport begin confronting fiscal crises, Mayor Michael Tucker said in response. -
Tucker: 'Best days lie ahead'
The City of Lockport government is smaller than it was 18 months ago but is in a stronger financial place, Mayor Michael W. Tucker said in his annual State of the City address.
-
Trio of new classes proposed for Newfane
Newfane High School could have three new business courses in the fall, one of which would center on video game design.
-
Municipalities take wait-and-see approach on SPCA funding
The City and Town of Lockport are each withholding payments to the Niagara SPCA, while other Eastern Niagara County towns are taking a wait-and-see approach.
-
Rocky II
Friends of Deputy Craig Beiter of the Niagara County Sheriff’s Department plan a benefit on Feb. 26 to raise money to buy and train a new dog for the K-9 Unit.
Beiter’s German shepherd, Deputy Rocky, was killed while on duty in December, and the sheriff’s department is close to getting a replacement. -
Basket Factory closes
The Basket Factory has gone out of business.
The owners, Julie Thompson Riegle and Dawn Thompson, made the difficult decision last Monday and put the sign on the door Tuesday. -
No snow is no problem
Unseasonably warm weather didn’t keep Roy-Hart Winterfest from being a fun day for the families who came out to Roy-Hart Elementary School on Saturday.
More than 500 people attended the third annual festivities, which Gasport Lions Club officials said was a big increase from last year. The halls of Roy-Hart Elementary were filled with vendors, programs and movement as excited children rushed from one activity to another. -
Shovel-ready park has perks
At first glance, the big, orange road sign announcing vacant property on Lockport Road as a “shovel ready certified” building site seems a bit gratuitous.
To companies looking for new places to launch a business, it’s not. The sign in their eyes is a welcome mat, for in three words a community pronounced itself ready, willing and able to make a deal quickly. -
Roy-Hart to play the big stage
A group of local students will be performing this month at Kleinhans Music Hall just before a BPO concert.
The Buffalo Philharmonic Orchestra will welcome the Royalton-Hartland High School Mixed Chorus as part of the BPO’s Community Spotlight program on Feb. 19 at Kleinhans in Buffalo. The chorus will perform under the direction of Carolyn Unitas Roos and accompanied by Janice McKinney. - More Local News Headlines
-
WIlson jumps on the 'bin wagon'
Obama Gives Education Waivers to 10 States
Giffords Aide to Run for Her Seat
LA School in Sex Abuse Scandal Reopens
Winter Slamming North Asia, Parts of Europe
Syrian Forces Renew Bombardment of Homs
States, Banks Reach Foreclosure-abuse Settlement
Raw Video: Italy's Mount Etna Bursts Into Life
Greeks March; Angry Despite Debt Deal
Raw Video: U.S. Pullout Celebration
Raw Video: Annual Empire State Building Run-Up
Man Killed in Courthouse Shootout
Air Force Airlines: Leaders Get Polished Service
Ga Girl Fights Off Kidnapper at Walmart
Nevada Highway Patrol, City Settle Beating Case
Homs Bombardment Continues, Global Outcry Grows
Raw Video: Dog Rescued From Icy Colo. Water
Skip the Coffee Cup and Inhale Your Caffeine Fix
