Editorials
GUEST EDITORIAL: Youth prisons need neutral monitor
The U.S. Justice Department probably will appoint a monitor to track New York’s progress in correcting serious problems — including the use of excessive force against kids — in the state’s juvenile prison system.
But the head of the state Office of Children and Family Services, which runs the juvenile prisons, said one of three consultants who’ve been working with OCFS to come up with reforms could be tapped as the monitor.
“It might be a more friendly type of monitor,” said Gladys Carrion, OCFS commissioner, at a Sept. 30 meeting of an advisory panel on juvenile justice. She added: “It looks like we might have some influence on who becomes the monitor.”
That would not be in the best interest of the children in state custody. Any monitor must be, above all, neutral. The monitor should not be in a position in which he or she might be concerned with offending the agency, which could be a source of lucrative contracts in the future.
Carrion said the state is not going to rebut or challenge any of the Justice Department’s findings from its investigation of four upstate youth prisons, including two outside Ithaca.
Federal investigators found that guards at the facilities were quick to use a high degree of force against the young inmates that was grossly disproportionate to any infractions the kids had made. Anything from sneaking an extra cookie to starting a fight to refusing to stop laughing resulted in youngsters being forced to the floor face-down and restrained with handcuffs. This one-size-fits-all approach to control led to an alarming number of serious injuries to the kids, including concussions, broken teeth and spinal fractures.
The Justice Department said OCFS failed to properly investigate these and other abuses and failed to take disciplinary action against abusive guards. Young inmates, many of whom suffered from mental problems, also received substandard mental health care. As many as half the kids at some of the prisons have some kind of mental illness.
OCFS is negotiating with the Justice Department on how it plans to correct these problems. A settlement is expected to be reached by the end of the year.
A monitor, appointed by the Justice Department but probably paid by the state, likely will make sure the state complies with the terms of the settlement.
So who will that be? A “friendly” face, as Carrion suggested might be possible? Or someone with no interest in pleasing the system being monitored?
The Justice Department has, in the past, appointed monitors who had worked for the agency being investigated, but that has been rare. There isn’t a blanket prohibition of the practice.
Carrion said the Justice Department is going to hold New York to a very high standard for change because of all the publicity over the abuses.
Appointing a “friendly” monitor, however, could guarantee that too much of what is wrong with the juvenile prison system will remain the same.
— The Post-Standard of Syracuse
- Editorials
-
-
Cuomo’s on his way
The stars seem to be aligning for Andrew Cuomo to claim the state's Executive Mansion as his home turf.
-
OTHER VIEW: School athletics model may need work
State and federal budget cuts arriving this year at levels far deeper than in the past will focus public attention on the value of combining the essential service of education and the significant, but secondary, service of school athletics.
-
OTHER VIEW: Travel is big business
U.S. Rep. Maurice Hinchey finished an editorial board meeting in Binghamton recently, he flipped through a few briefing papers. There was a key piece of information he wanted to remind editors of before he left the room.
-
OTHER VIEW: Don’t invest in Iran
It’s an inexact calculation at best, putting a dollar figure on the undermined credibility of a legitimate U.S. effort to pressure Iran into thinking better of trying to develop nuclear weapons. Still, it’s worth a try.
-
OTHER VIEW: Lawyers upheld American ideals
In the McCarthy era, demagogues on the right smeared loyal Americans as disloyal and charged that the government was being undermined from within. In this era, demagogues on the right are smearing loyal Americans as disloyal and charging that the government is being undermined from within.
-
OTHER VIEW: State needs to look toward meaningful reform
As New Yorkers grapple with the latest scandals enveloping their governor, the state faces some harsh fiscal realities — and the budget-approval deadline is rapidly approaching.
-
OTHER VIEW: Clean up, protect the Great Lakes
The Great Lakes finally are in line for real restoration work — beyond the hold-the-line effort that has been showing signs of slowing or actually reversing course.
-
OTHER VIEW: Give Senate a chance to vote on medical marijuana
Imagine, an open and honest debate in the state Senate, and on a very relevant and substantive issue. What happens all too rarely could happen quite soon, on the topic of legalizing the use of marijuana for medicinal purposes.
-
OTHER VIEW: Goals and standards make great schools
Yet another educational study has emerged and is now debated within a discipline forever searching for new figures, new emerging trends, new and unique methods for squeezing as much improvement in student performance that might be possible. This new study making rounds within the educational establishment is noteworthy in the way it dismisses the stylish in favor of common wisdom and the tried and true.
-
OTHER VIEW: Stand by Kendra’s Law
New Yorkers need effective protection against violent attacks by the mentally ill, and the deeply troubled need proper treatment to prevent them from bloodily losing control.
- More Editorials Headlines
-
Cuomo’s on his way
