MARREN: Changes to endorsement process

Columns

October 24, 2009

By Tim Marren<br><a href="mailto:tim.marren@lockportjournal.com">E-mail Tim</a> The Lockport Union-Sun %26 Journal Sat Oct 24, 2009, 11:46 PM EDT

A few weeks ago we gathered as an Editorial Board and cranked out a game plan for our endorsement process. It’s a change from the usual format where we invite the candidates in, one by one, interview them for about an hour or so and decide a few days later who we support in each race.

This year we decided to bring both candidates in at the same time. We looked at it as a mini-debate of sorts, where our Editorial Board served as the moderators and audience.

Having both candidates per race in at the same time has made for an interesting experience so far. We’ve had the Town of Lockport supervisor’s race, two city council races and the Lockport Town Board candidates (well, three of four). All have brought something different.

What this format does, though, is hold them accountable to each other. Where in the past we might interview candidate A on a Monday and candidate B on that Wednesday, candidate B might say something about A after we had already talked to that person. Now we either need to discount what B alleged or go back to candidate A and verify the claim from his opponent. It turns into a big game of “he said, she said.”

Having them all in the room together hasn’t limited the allegations, that’s for sure. No one has been shy. You have the immediate chance for fact-checking with the opposition sitting right there — or just plain rebuttal.

We keep the interviews to about an hour, with both candidates having five minutes or so to introduce themselves and give reasons why they are running. Those who we’ve had in so far seem to appreciate the process, and those who knew the old way seem to prefer the new method. They say it’s fair. That’s our goal.

The endorsement process for newspapers is an interesting one that has been tradition. Some say it should go away since it may show some sort of bias. Not true. When you have a newspaper’s Editorial Board questioning the candidates on both sides of the aisle, you become an extension of the readers, the voting public, that may not have that opportunity. We question those running and decide who we think would represent you best.

So far, so good on the new format. Hopefully, next year we can tweak it a little more and invite the public to attend and make it a forum.

•••

SIDE NOTE: Bill “The Butcher” Richardson — running in the First Ward — has declined all endorsements and included the US&J; as part of that stance. Scott Hughes — running in the Fifth Ward — declined an interview, stating that his soccer coaching duties make it difficult. David Devereaux declined, saying he would be out of town the day we met with the other three Lockport Town Board candidates.

David Leible, who is running for Pendleton supervisor, won’t get my personal endorsement and since he is blowing off the newspaper’s Editorial Board, will not get our overall endorsement either. This guy says he didn’t get our e-mail invite, but I never got a bounced e-mail back that his address was wrong. I called him to follow up, and the man I have never talked to immediately went on the offensive, saying “why should I waste my time if you’re not going to endorse me anyway?” Not knowing where he was coming from, I asked him why. “Well you didn’t endorse me last time ...” Not sure what this guy ran for, but he probably didn’t deserve it then, either, if this is the way he acts. I think it may have been for Town Board. We didn’t even endorse in that race last time. So in the end, he was too cowardly to meet with the newspaper, but did get one thing right after his rant. We’re not going to endorse him. Hopefully, that sequence of events helps voters make their choice as well.

Tim Marren is the managing editor of the Lockport Union-Sun

& Journal. Contact him at Tim.Marren@lockportjournal.com or 439-9222.

Text Only

Columns

LEFFLER: The things that actually matter
To hear some people tell it, this great republic of ours is on the brink of disintegration.

May 22, 2012 1 Photo
Your friends are great ... at Facebook
The internet has been the facilitator of a lot of good things; it allows us to comparison shop without putting on pants, lets people check the weather report without having to watch the rest of the news and it’s made keeping in touch with friends and family a breeze; cruising through Facebook seeing pictures of your friend from high school’s new baby, a twitter feed full of self-promoting tweets about your neighbor’s new online start-up, a status update from your nephew that talks about meeting Buffalo Bills legend Jim Kelly. Reading all of these updates from the exciting lives of your friends and family while you sit at home, it can at times feel like everyone is living the dream but you.

May 17, 2012 1 Photo
The war against the English language
April 25, 2012
VINCENT DAVIS II: Oil prices and the 'Bro-conomy'
Can we be serious for a moment; not too long, but longer than usual? Gas prices are going up folks. US oil drilling is at its highest point in more than 10 years. But when Toyota Prius commercials come on TV during sporting events, we know longer make fun of them for advertising a “fake car” that “only a hippy or English professor would drive.” Instead, we think to ourselves “40 miles a gallon, that does sound nice ...”

March 16, 2012 1 Photo
‘Mailing it in’ is not good enough
The U.S. Postal Service has been mailing it in for years. It has stuck like an old postage stamp to a business model that was going nowhere fast, literally. Snail mail is still the USPS stock in trade, and it has increasingly earned its nickname. And for a poorly run operation, it certainly does cost a lot. USPS must offer competitive shipping options, guaranteed faster delivery times and overall service enhancements — or the death spiral of an American institution will continue.

March 2, 2012
Gadgets Galore
The 2012 International Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas has come and gone, but the gadgets introduced there likely will be part of our future for years to come. Record numbers were set with attendance, vendors, and square footage of exhibit space. Innovations were unveiled, and in some cases, expectations dashed.

January 29, 2012 5 Photos
LEFFLER: I remember the scream
If you’re sick of news of the run for the White House, I’ve got some really bad news for you: It’s about to get worse.

January 3, 2012 1 Photo
Put some Apple accessories under the tree this year
December 18, 2011 6 Photos
War of 1812 has lots of connections to us
December 17, 2011
Don’t overlook freedom
November 13, 2011
More Columns Headlines

Columns

Search Results

MARREN: Changes to endorsement process

Site Map

Contact Us