Columns
Related Photos
Tools
MARREN: Off-the-record is on-the-record
LOCKPORT — For those who didn’t catch it because of all the Leodis McKelvin coverage this week, President Obama called rapper Kanye West a jackass.
If you were a Western New Yorker watching television early this week you had a good chance of seeing either the West blunder on Sunday or the McKelvin blunder on Monday. Both were all the talk late into Monday night and certainly the rest of the week.
West was criticized for interrupting Swift as she accepted an award at Sunday’s MTV Video Music Awards to say that Beyonce deserved it instead.
Obama went on to call West a jackass when he thought he was in an off-the-record discussion with CNBC before an interview.
The president and CNBC’s John Harwood were making small talk while the camera guys were setting up. Talk got to West and his selfish move.
“I thought that was really inappropriate,” Obama says. “What are you butting in (for)? ... The young lady seems like a perfectly nice person. She’s getting her award. What’s he doing up there?”
A questioner in the same room chimes in, “Why would he do it?”
“He’s a jackass,” Obama replies, which is met with laughter from several people.
The president realized he said something stupid and that chances were really good that a mic was live. It was.
ABC reporters, who overheard the conversation with CNBC’s crew, Twittered that the president just called West a Jackass. Gossip site TMZ.com had the audio. It caught like wildfire.
By the end of the week discussion started focusing on the great on-the-record, off-the-record debate with journalists.
Here’s my thing: I hate off-the-record. I don’t think the term should exist because the usage shouldn’t exist. The president, politicians, people of so-called power, athletes and really anyone who talks to a reporter should either say what you want quoted or don’t say anything you wouldn’t want to see quoted.
If you don’t say it, you can’t expect it to be quoted. If you don’t say it a reporter won’t be confused as to whether something is on or off-the-record.
If you know in the back of your mind that something you’re about to utter is off-the-record, just don’t say it at all.
Now this isn’t an endorsement of my next favorite, “no comment,” it’s just a plea for those being interviewed to make everything on the record or don’t say what you don’t want quoted.
What we also run into are the types who say “off-the-record,” with hopes that the reporter will report it with unnamed sources or through another source that will go on-the-record. The cynic in me says this is intentional to still get their scandalous “you didn’t hear it from me, but...” news in the news, without it coming from to them.
Too often it does and that person gets burned and then everyone is ticked.
But this situation is different.
Obama, like Bush, who was constantly saying stupid things, and all the presidents before the two of them, are never truthfully off-the-record.
As any good electronic journalist will tell you, if there’s a mic in the room, assume it’s on. It’s what even some veteran news broadcasters forget and what makes for great outakes, but it’s something the president should know full well.
Watch what you say — always.
I still believe journalists can be trusted and credibility still dominates, despite what some may say. But I also believe off-the-record is just senseless chatter that just leads to problems.
If you’re talking to a reporter, you’re on the record.
Tim Marren is the managing
editor of the Lockport Union-Sun
& Journal. Contact him at Tim.Marren@lockportjournal.com or 439-9222.
- Columns
-
-
FROM THE VALLEY: No charge for paying attention
“You can learn more with your ears than you can with your mouth.” That's great advice.
-
The soundtrack to spring
My van and I have been through nine spring rituals together. This year will be the 10th. The ritual has been the same every year, and I really do not intend to change it.
-
LEFFLER: The good life in Western New York
Oh look! Spring. Now, technically I know it’s not spring yet, but with the Ides of March and Buffalo’s St. Patrick’s Day parade in our rear-view, two of the indicators I use for spring have already passed.
-
DRINKWALTER: The Dominican adventure
I was never as happy to be back in the USA as I was when our Jet Blue flight came skidding down the runway at the Buffalo airport a few weeks ago. Even if the air controller’s kid might have been the one to usher us in, Jet Blue was our salvation. We had arrived home from “a long strange trip” to the Dominican Republic.
-
MARREN: Shine some light on government
In the newspaper industry, there is always an interest, and rightfully so, in shining light on public figures, contracts, salaries and more government business.
-
WOLCOTT: World War II vets have a way of being remembered
After I interviewed Kenneth Moss at his Cambria-Wilson Road home for a story that’s coming in our Pride Magazine in April, he stopped me at the kitchen door.
-
TOM CHRISTY: New York state's got a borrowing addiction
New York state is in fiscal crisis — but that’s just too easy to say. It rolls off the tongue far too easily and sounds far less dire than the situation actually is.
-
FROM THE VALLEY: SpaghettiOs and ‘wascal wabbits’
I thought it was worth recognizing several people who have passed away since the start of the relatively new year. I share them with you as a “tip of the hat” for their contributions.
-
GEORGE ROOT: Breaking the chains
I am not a young person anymore. Recently, I have been able to embrace that notion and start to work with it.
-
LEFFLER: Too many questions
“We can’t move forward until you mail it back. ”That little slogan has been frustrating me now since I first heard it a couple months ago.
- More Columns Headlines
-
